Directed by Fritz Lang; produced by Walter Wanger and Fritz Lang
Meek bank teller Chris Cross (Edward G Robinson), leaving a company dinner celebrating his 25 years’ service, comes across Kitty March (Joan Bennett) being hit by a man (Dan Duryea). Cross inadvertently knocks the assailant out, and Kitty rewards Cross by allowing him to buy her a drink. Almost immediately, he is infatuated with the younger, attractive woman, an emotional step which is just the first in his degrading downfall.
A re-make of a French film of thirteen years before, Scarlet Street re-unites the stars of the previous year’s The Woman in the Window. This later movie is a bleak, not really satisfying film. The story is reminiscent of Sternberg’s The Blue Angel. Indeed, that director and Lang shared many traits, not the least of which were their Viennese origins. The story is similar in its outline: a middle aged man becomes infatuated with a young, beautiful woman who humiliates and discards him. But there is something lacking in Scarlet Street that The Blue Angel has.
Part of the problem is Robinson’s performance. It never convinces the audience that Cross is really so far gone on Kitty that he could even be driven to murder. There is not the investment of the character in the situation that persuades the viewer. Instead, Cross seems less enamoured of Kitty than in need of her friendship. That too is betrayed but there is no passion that dictates such drastic actions as Cross takes.
The other actors are good. Bennett is suitably callous and evil, and Duryea plays a crueller and more opportunistic version of the villain he perfected.
The story is a good one, though I was ambivalent about the art angle: Cross is an amateur - and rather untalented - painter, whose works are eventually hailed as masterpieces. That the credit is taken by others is dramatically feasible. That people consider the pictures worthy of display in prestigious galleries strikes one as satire. I kept thinking that this was an old SCTV skit. And why was it set in 1934?
As well, Cross seems far too gullible. It’s true that such is his character that he naturally has a hard time differentiating true feelings from fake, but even so, a reasonably intelligent man should have been a bit more on his guard. And his thieving was simplistic at best; as an experienced teller, he should have been circumspect in his embezzlement.
The movie’s conclusion is probably the best part, in that it may have been the first Hollywood film to feature a criminal getting away with his crimes - though whether he actually does so in terms of justice, as opposed to the law, is another matter. That he did not face “orthodox punishment”, as one contemporary review put it, caused the movie to be censored in some American markets. But it gives Scarlet Street a style that seems European and sophisticated for the time - not surprising, considering the source - but which would increasingly be taken on by American films, especially those of the noir genre.
Lang’s direction is, predictably, very good. There are plenty of instances of him playing with shadows and light, and a snide but effective reference to someone’s execution in the flickering of a room’s electric lights. If Lang had had Robinson give a stronger, more involved performance, the movie would have been improved.
Scarlet Street is an adequate movie that could have been better. Perhaps it was thought that the impetus from the previous years The Woman in the Window would carry Scarlet Street when other elements failed. If so, it was an erroneous assumption.












































