Directed by Joseph H Lewis; produced
by Wallace MacDonald
A young woman (Nina Foch), searching
for a job, is hired as a secretary by an elderly woman (May Whitty), who has
her new employee come to live with her and her son (George Macready). When she wakes
after what she thinks is one night, the woman finds herself in a country house,
having lost a day and being called a completely different name. Her identity
stolen, a prisoner, and fearing the worst, she doesn’t have long to find a way
out of her deadly predicament.
A short (65 minutes) ‘B’ picture, My Name is Julia Ross is almost ruined
by the story; how much of it came from the novel The Woman in Red by the famous crime-writer Anthony Gilbert, I
don’t know. As may be guessed from my first paragraph, the nefarious intentions
of those who hire Foch are not long kept from the viewer, so I give nothing
away in describing them. They are, in fact, revealed within minutes of Whitty
and Macready appearing on the screen. Thus, one of the plot devices of similar
movies – the doubt the audience, and the protagonist, have regarding somebody’s
sanity – is immediately discarded. Foch seems to have been lately ill - her
‘recovery’ is mentioned, as is someone else’s appendix removal – but her mental
or emotional state, other than anxiety over trying to find a job, is not in
question. Indeed, that she herself believes the masquerade over her new
identity is unimportant to her enemies.
Since the story deliberately does
away with a possibly central cause of tension in the movie, it is up to other
elements to create a successful film. Fortunately, they are up to the task. The
script, while not particularly imaginative, creates a smart and sympathetic
main character. At no point does Foch think that she is losing her mind. She
knows something wicked is afoot, and she devotes her considerable intelligence
to thwarting it. That numerous schemes for escape fail is due to bad luck and
the nearly equal brains of her captors. That little time or effort is given to
filling out her character detracts a little.
The acting also contributes. Foch,
at the beginning of a long and varied entertainment career, is convincing as
the heroine, someone thrown by circumstances upon her own resources; that she
probably had to rely on them most of her young life is implied. May Whitty
(credited as ‘Dame May Whitty’, having been made a dame of the Order of the
British Empire for her charitable work in the Great War) gives a rare
performance as a villainess. Even at eighty, she is lively and believable in
her role. Macready’s performance, if not well-known, will be remembered once
seen. His slightly goggle-eyed stare and calm demeanour, ready to vanish in a
paradoxically emotionless rage, is chilling. And his nearly normal praise of
the sea’s ability to keep silent indicates where his previous victim was
deposited. (As a footnote, the heroine’s love-interest is played by Roland
Varno. Coincidentally, he was born Dutch, as was Foch, and, like her, had a
strong connection with the Netherlands East Indies (now Indonesia).)
While not in the first rank of
thrillers, My Name is Julia Ross is a
good entry in the Gothic/psychological melodrama sub-genre, thanks to the
acting and characters. And, with its short running time, a viewer needs only an
hour to be given an evening’s entertainment.
I’ve read “The Woman in Red.” This sounds like a pretty loose adaptation. The novel is more of a spy thriller. (And a pretty good one, too.)
ReplyDeleteI wonder sometimes why studios buy rights to stories, since the movie that results is often different than the book. In this case, they didn't even use the book's title for publicity. I have seen several so-called adaptations of Conrad's "The Secret Agent", and each of them is fundamentally different.
DeleteHave you seen some of the recent Agatha Christie adaptations? Argh.
ReplyDeleteI refuse to. When I noted that Tommy and Tuppence were working with Miss Marple in one episode, I needed to know no more. From what else I have heard, my decision was by far the best I've ever made.
DeleteTo me, David Suchet's series of Poirot stories, and Joan Hickson as Miss Marple, were the ultimate in their respective stories' adaptations.
I see it on uTube..with a running time
ReplyDeleteof 1.05.02..so, l shall settle down later
this afternoon and give it a whirl..! :o).
Thankyou John..!
Sounds like a good one.
ReplyDelete